I think this would have been a very good bout between 2 very slick counterpunchers.
James Toney-Had the faster hands and slightly better defence in my opinion. Had a rock hard jaw but wasn't the greatest when it came to being in shape.Movement troubled Toney.Toney had some pop to his punches.
EM-Slick counter puncher with the edge in power over Toney.Also had a great chin but like Toney wasn't the best at getting into shape.I think EM would also be stronger then Toney.I think EM was also very accurate with his counters.His biggest weakness it seems was his motivation and being outworked in some of his bouts.
If Toney and EM both showed up at there best at lightheavy who would win?