The comparison stinks IMO.
Lets be real here and this is what I feared after Pac won; everyone saying how brilliant it was. Pac did what he had to do and was very good, no doubt about it; but let us analyse what he actually faced:
This is what I was afraid of. I watched that fight and I have boxed many times and I have to say; I have never seen such a novice like performance from a so called legend ever. It was beyong deplorable and no amount of excuses can save Oscar. Weight, tactics etc etc. Manny did well and boxed beautiful and all credit to him; but to use this victory over a SHAM Oscar as some barometer to his future success against legitimate welters is IMO misguided. Even Manny himself could not understand why Oscar was so dreadful He clapped his gloves together at one point as if to say 'what the hell is up with you?'
Okay, how can anyone explain a guy getting repeatedly hit in the face with straight lefts. What can explain Oscar's diabolical flat footed approach. He could not even judge simple distance. All this was happening to a man who had all the physical advantages, no matter what HBO reported on the weights; the actual look of both men in the RING told the true story. 4 inches taller and a 5 inch reach advantage. Even excusing him being past it, which I and everyone else knows, I believe a man off the street would have done better. Nothing explains this performance. I am honestly trying to find a reason but I can't. All I can think of is that Oscar simply had a meltdown and was suffering with his vision and balance.
For the last two rds, he couldn't even throw a shot. Manny hit Oscar at will; but were any of the shots hard? I say NO, they were just accumulation shots. He was being hit by a blown up feather. Very strange indeed and IMO this win should really be taken in context. Manny himself was utterly shocked at how poor Oscar was!
Now, to compare a 35 year old Oscar fighting a man who is really two to three weights below him and cowering for the last two rds from Pac's
DEVASTATING
shots, to a man suffering with Parkinson's is simply absurd. I will give Oscar a pass, because I truly believe Oscar was suffering from some sort of condition the other night. It is the only thing to explain how he actually performed. His 2 lb weight gain in over 24 hrs is really really odd.
Bookmarks