1888
Jan 14 Ed Cahill Brooklyn, NY L 3
Feb 11 Dan Custy in New Jersey D 27
-Custy was called the Champion of Long Island
Dec 10 Edward "Rug" McDonald New York, NY WF 7
-This is the same boxer who fought "Nonpareil" Jack Dempsey
Dec 26 Jack Dougherty Brooklyn, NY EX
1889
May 14 Jack Dougherty Brooklyn, NY ND
-The men fought for a full minute after time was called
1890
Jan 12 -Reynolds went to greet Jack Fallon who had returned
from Europe on the "Germania" of the White Star line
May 10 Frank Duff Chicago, Il EX
1891
Dec 26 Martin Snee New York, NY W 6
1892
Feb 6 Paddy McCarty New York, NY TK 15
Apr 14 John Sampson Brooklyn, NY W 3
-Sampson was the former Amateur Lightweight Champion of America
Apr 30 Walter Campbell Philadelphia, Pa SCH
-This bout was scheduled; The outcome is not known
May 2 Jack Thornton Astoria, NY LT 5
May 7 Martin Snee New York, NY W
Jun 22 Al O'Brien New York, NY LK 2
-Some sources report 07/22/1892; Some sources report "LK 3"
Jul 20 -The Brooklyn (NY) Daily Eagle reported that Reynolds had filed a law suit
against the Manhattan AC for the balance of payment due him from the
Al O'Brien bout
Aug 24 Jim Sweeney New York, NY TK 11
-Some sources report 10/24/1892
Sep 19 Jim Sampson Philadelphia, Pa EX
Oct 1 "Texas" Jack Burke New York, NY L 6
Oct 3 -Reynolds refereed the Casper Leon-Sammy Myers bout in New York, NY
Nov 11 Owen Ziegler Philadelphia, Pa SCH
-This bout was scheduled but cancelled
Dec 26 -Reynolds seconded Joe Daly vs Billy Welch in New York, NY
1893
Jan 29 Owen Ziegler Philadelphia, Pa LK 6
Feb 4 Owen Ziegler Philadelphia, Pa ND 4
Feb 17 Billy Ahearn New York, NY L
-Perhaps, this is a reference to the 02/17/1894 bout
Apr 29 Johnny Young Brooklyn, NY TK 4
Jun 22 Mike Leonard Brooklyn, NY LT 10
-Some sources report "LK 9"
Sep 29 an unnamed opponent Hoboken, NJ W
1894
Jan 11 Mike Leonard New York, NY ND 6
Jan 25 James Fox Philadelphia, Pa SCH
-This bout was scheduled; The outcome is not known
Feb 17 Billy Ahearn New York, NY L 4
Sep 3 Billy Ahearn near New York, NY SCH
-This bout was scheduled; The outcome is not known
Sep 25 Billy Ahearn Long Island, NY SCH
-This bout was scheduled for a "finish" but not held;
Ahearn refused to fight because Reynolds would
not change the gloves he wanted for larger ones
Oct 29 -Reynolds seconded Johnny T. Griffin vs George "Kid" Lavigne in Brooklyn, NY
1895
Feb 2 -Reynolds challenged Al O'Brien to a bout
Feb 5 -The Brooklyn (NY) Daily Eagle reported Reynolds was willing to fight
Johnny Gorman in a bout of limited rounds or to a finish
Apr 11 Young Griffo Albany, NY ND 6
May 2 Billy Duke Baltimore, Md D 8
May 13 Billy Welch New York, NY W 8
May 18 Billy Ernst Brooklyn, NY D 8
Aug 19 George "Elbows" McFadden New York, NY W 3
Oct 12 George "Elbows" McFadden New York, NY L 4
1896
George "Elbows" McFadden New York, NY L 3
1897
Jun an unnamed opponent London, England EX
Oct 18 Johnny Hughes London, England L 8
1898
Sep 3 Billy Ernst Brooklyn, NY LK 4
Review courtesy of
Tracy Callis,
Historian, International Boxing Research Organization
|