Undated
Tom Lee TK 2
T. Cavanaugh Kansas City, Mo TK 9
Ed Thompson Kansas City, Mo TK 1
Tom Kearney Kansas City, Mo TK 2
Jim Marshall D 20
1891
Aug 7 John Condon Omaha, Ne KO 7
Nov 11 Charley Heenan Omaha, Ne KO 6
1892
Aug 11 Jim Porter Minneapolis, Mn KO 23
1893
May 8 Solomon "Solly" Smith St. Paul, Mn EX 6
-Some sources report 6/10/93;
Smith failed to knockout Gardner
Jun 17 Ed Schultenberg Omaha, Ne TK 11
Jul 31 Tommy Dixon St. Paul, Mn LK 13
1894
Mar 13 Dominick Barnes Minneapolis, Mn KO 5
Mar 29 John Van Heest Minneapolis, Mn NC 41
-Some sources report "D 40"
Aug 6 Jack O'Keefe Kansas City, Mo D 10
Sep 5 "Young" Jack Dempsey St. Paul, Mn W 4
Nov 9 Jack Collins St. Joseph, Mo W 6
Nov 27 Solomon "Solly" Smith Buffalo, NY WF 5
-Gardner broke his arm in the first round
1895
Jan 26 Jim Evans Kansas City, Mo KO 3
Mar 11 Lon Agnew Kansas City, Mo W 4
Mar 31 Mike Delougherty Leavenworth, Ks KO 2
May 26 Tommy Dixon Kansas City, Mo LK 36
Aug 15 Billy O'Donnell Memphis, Tn LT 18
Oct 6 George Stout Kansas City, Mo WF 12
Dec 2 John Van Heest Excelsior Springs, Mo ND 6
1896
Mar 9 Eugene Bezenah Covington, Ky D 15
May 22 Pete Shea Dayton, Oh KO 4
1897
Feb 6 Bradford Branch Kansas City, Mo KO 6
Mar 13 Solomon "Solly" Smith New York, NY L 20
Mar 27 Billy O'Brien New York, NY KO 4
Apr 1 Jack Grant New York, NY KO 9
Apr 10 "Torpedo" Billy Murphy New York, NY W 20
Apr 19 Austin Rice New York, NY D 20
May 10 James "Rube" Ferns Chicopee, Ks D 6
Jun 5 Maxie Haugh Brooklyn, NY W 10
-Some sources report "W 15"
Jul 12 Jack "Doc" Hamilton Troy, NY D 12
Jul 19 "New York" Jack O'Brien Albany, NY D 10
Aug 30 "New York" Jack O'Brien New York, NY D 20
Sep 15 Tommy Dixon Rochester, NY W 20
Oct 6 John Van Heest Lexington, Ky KO 11
Oct 18 Luke Stevens Rochester, NY KO 6
Nov 13 "New York" Jack O'Brien New York, NY W 15
Nov 18 Billy Rotchford Buffalo, NY L 20
Nov 19 John Van Heest Dayton, Oh D 20
Nov 29 George Stout Cincinnati, Oh D 15
Dec 13 Eugene Bezenah Cincinnati, Oh D 15
Dec 22 Johnny Lavack Cincinnati, Oh W 10
1898
Jan 11 Eugene Bezenah Wheeling, WV TK 21
Feb 21 Luke Stevens Buffalo, NY KO 9
Feb 22 Jack O'Keefe Wheeling, WV KO 18
Mar 17 Patsy Haley Buffalo, NY D 20
Mar 22 Mike Farragher Columbus, Oh KO 3
Apr 7 George Stout Columbus, Oh KO 12
-Stout died from injuries sustained in this bout
May 23 Fred Bogan Wheeling, WV KO 12
-Some sources report 5/25/1898
Jun 6 Jerry Marshall Wheeling, WV TK 13
Jun 30 Jack McClelland Wheeling, WV KO 10
Jul 4 Jim Marshall Zanesville, Oh ND 6
Jul 11 Eugene Bezenah Bridgeport, Ct D 40
Aug 22 Joe Hopkins Buffalo, NY W 20
Aug 24 Danny McMahon Toledo, Oh KO 5
Sep 9 Sam Bolen New York, NY KO 10
Sep 16 Jim Marshall Louisville, Ky KO 6
Oct 28 Sammy Kelly New York, NY KO 14
Nov 3 Frank Bradley Philadelphia, Pa ND 6
Nov 12 Joe Fairburn Philadelphia, Pa ND 6
Nov 29 George Dixon New York, NY L 25
-Featherweight Championship of the World
Dec 27 Frank Bradley Wheeling, WV W 20
1899
Jan 8 Dave Sullivan New York, NY KO 17
-Some sources report 1/09/99
Jan 23 Tommy "Kid" Hogan Pittsburgh, Pa ND 10
Feb 7 Solomon "Solly" Smith New York, NY TK 6
Feb 13 "New York" Jack O'Brien Youngstown, Oh L 20
Feb 22 Martin Flaherty Hartford, Ct D 20
Feb 27 Joe Hopkins Cincinnati, Oh W 10
Mar 15 Jimmy Murray Hot Springs, Ar D 20
-Some sources report 3/16/99
Mar 20 Fred Bogan Hot Springs, Ar KO 5
Mar 25 Eugene Bezenah Indianapolis, In D 10
Apr 11 Billy O'Donnell New York, NY WF 6
Apr 18 Joe Hopkins Wheeling, WV KO 19
-Some sources report "KO 15"
May 4 Tommy "Kid" Hogan Louisville, Ky W 20
May 12 Martin Flaherty New York, NY D 25
Sep 22 Jack "Doc" Hamilton New York, NY L 25
Sep 25 Ben Jordan Brooklyn, NY SCH
-This bout was scheduled; The outcome is not known
Oct 26 Ben Jordan Brooklyn, NY SCH
-This bout was scheduled; The outcome is not known
Nov 6 Marty McCue Brooklyn, NY L 25
Nov 14 Jack "Doc" Hamilton New York, NY W 25
Nov 21 Tim Callahan Paterson, NJ D 20
Dec 1 Harry Forbes Chicago, Il D 6
1900
Feb 20 Tommy White Chicago, Il ND 6
-Reports vary - "W 6" - "D 6"
Mar 9 Terry McGovern New York, NY LK 3
-Featherweight Championship of the World
Mar 28 Patsy Haley Shawnee, Oh KO 3
-Some sources report 3/29/00
Apr 10 Jack "Doc" Hamilton Wheeling, WV D 20
Apr 27 Joe Bernstein New York, NY TK 16
-Some sources report "W 16"
Apr 30 Patsy Haley Cincinnati, Oh KO 5
May 3 Eddie Santry Louisville, Ky TK 5
-Some sources report "W 5"
May 10 Ned "Kid" Broad New York, NY WF 17
May 28 Gus Bezenah Cincinnati, Oh KO 4
May 28 Larry Gleason Cincinnati, Oh KO 3
Jun 1 Harry Forbes Chicago, Il KO 1
Jun 12 Billy Ryan Cleveland, Oh KO 18
-Some sources report 6/13/00
Jun 15 Billy Barrett New York, NY WF 14
Jul 2 Jack McClelland Millvale, Pa D 20
-Some sources report 7/04/00
Jul 8 Eddie Santry Kansas City, Mo L 20
-Some sources report 7/06/00
Jul 27 Eddie Lenny New York, NY TK 21
-Some sources report "W 21"
Aug 9 Eugene Garcia Wheeling, WV KO 3ae
Aug 23 Joe Bernstein New York, NY WF 12
-Reports vary - 8/12/00 - 8/27/00
Sep 10 Sammy Phillips Louisville, Ky TK 4
-Some sources report "WF 4"
Sep 24 Tim Callahan Philadelphia, Pa ND 6
Oct 4 Eddie Lenny Newark, Oh W 20
Oct 8 Dave Sullivan Louisville, Ky LT 14
-Reports state that the referee actually held Gardner back
and allowed Sullivan to hit him; Some sources report "L 14"
Oct 13 Ole Oleson Chicago, Il L 6
Oct 25 Harry Smith Omaha, Ne KO 16
Nov 6 Martin Flaherty Hartford, Ct ND 12
-During round twelve, the men became entangled while fighting and fell to the floor;
Each man was banged up a bit and the fight was stopped
Dec 3 Jack "Doc" Hamilton Youngstown, Oh L 20
Dec 6 Dick "Buck" Stelzer Marietta, Oh D 20
1901
Jan 7 Tim Callahan Boston, Ma LK 15
Jan 15 Tommy "Kid" Hogan Memphis, Tn KO 6
Jan 18 Tommy Dixon Weir City, Ks W 10
Feb 8 Johnny Burns Alexandria, Ne D 20
Feb 15 Haich Smith Tilden, Ne D 20
Feb 18 Tommy Dixon Galena, Ks D 20
Apr 30 Terry McGovern San Francisco, Ca LK 4
-Featherweight Championship of the World
Jun 26 Young Corbett II Denver, Co LT 6
Jul 3 Johnny Ritchie South Omaha, Ne L 20
-Some sources report "Memphis, Tn"
Oct 8 Clarence Forbes Kansas City, Mo LT 9
Oct 15 Clarence Ritchie St. Louis, Mo LF 3
1902
Clarence English LK 4
*** The Following Bouts Are Reported But Not Confirmed ***
1895
May 12 Martin Flaherty New York, NY D 25
-Perhaps, this bout is a reference to the 05/12/1899 bout
1898
Jul 3 Danny McMahon W 6