1886
Dec Billy Davis New York, NY SCH
-This bout was scheduled but postponed; Police presence prevented it
1887
Jan 14 Billy Davis New York, NY D 30
Mar 11 Nat Morris Westchester County, NY KO 9
Mar 25 Jack Kenny White Plains, NY LK 15
-Some sources report Hornbacker fought "William Penny";
Reports vary - "L 15" - "D 15"
Aug 25 -Hornbacker seconded Billy Davis vs Hugh Boyle in New York, NY
Nov 23 Jim Burke New York, NY KO 2
-Some sources report "Mickey Burke"
1888
Jan 11 Billy Clarkson New York, NY TK 15
Jan 17 Swipes, the Newsboy New York, NY D 6
Feb 16 Jack Grace New York, NY EX
Feb 25 Swipes, the Newsboy Brooklyn, NY EX 4
Feb 25 Joe Fowler Brooklyn, NY EX
-The previous 2 bouts were held the same date
Apr 13 Johnny T. Griffin Boston, Ma L 7
Apr 23 Larry White near Hoboken, NJ WF 25
-Some sources report "Sol White";
This bout was held on a barge on the North River;
Some sources report 04/24/1888 in New York, NY
Apr 19 Swipes, the Newsboy Brooklyn, NY EX
-Some sources report 04/10/1888
Jun 1 Larry Boylan near Yonkers, NY TK 9
-This bout was held on a barge in the river nearby
Sep 17 Charles "Cal" McCarthy New York, NY LF 21
-Bantamweight Championship of America (American version);
Some sources report 09/28/1888; Some sources report "LF 22"
Oct 12 Tommy "Spider" Kelly Blissville, NY D 15
1889
Jan 18 Jimmy Oliver New York, NY ND
Jan 18 Frank Donovan New York, NY ND
-The previous 2 bouts were held the same date
Jan 23 -Hornbacker was challenged by Walter Halligan to a bout at 122 lbs
Feb 4 -Hornbacher was scheduled to spar in Hoboken, NJ
Feb 25 Billy Clarkson Hoboken, NJ ND
Mar 9 E. Lynch New York, NY L 4
-Lynch was much larger and heavier than Hornbacker
Mar 21 Ed Roberts New York, NY EX
Apr 14 Tim Collins New York, NY D 10
May 10 -Hornbacker seconded Jimmy Hogan vs Mike Smith at Long Island, NY
Jun 13 an unnamed opponent New York, NY EX
Jim Walters W 6
Jimmy Lynch New York, NY L 4
Sep 13 William Hass New York, NY EX
Sep 23 Charles "Cal" McCarthy New York, NY SCH
-This bout was scheduled but postponed
Dec 22 Larry Boylan Brooklyn, NY SCH
-This bout was scheduled; The outcome is not known
Dec 27 George Dixon New London, Ct LK 2
1890
Jan 22 Eddie Dailey New York, NY KO 30
May 12 Charles "Cal" McCarthy Brooklyn, NY EX 3
Oct 27 Jack Wallace Elizabeth, NJ SCH
-This bout was scheduled; The outcome is not known
1891
Jan 27 Frank "Scotty" Cox Brooklyn, NY LF 9
Feb 7 Peter Baker Brooklyn, NY SCH
-This bout was scheduled; The outcome is not known
Oct 22 Pat Daly Stamford, Ct KO 9
Nov 27 an unnamed opponent New York, NY EX
Nov 3 George Dixon New York, NY EX 4
1892
Feb 6 Kentucky Rosebud New York, NY L 6
-This man was "Walter Edgerton"; Some sources report "L 5"
Feb 15 Sim Collins Philadelphia, Pa ND 10
-Some sources report "Brooklyn, NY"
Mar 24 George Strong Fishkill, NY LF 18
Apr 30 Sim Collins New York, NY L 10
Jul 31 Pat Daly Brooklyn, NY TK 5
-Some sources report "Red Bank, NJ"
Oct 8 Jack Lynch Philadelphia, Pa SCH
-This bout was scheduled; The outcome is not known
Oct Jim Crowe SCH
-This bout was scheduled; The outcome is not known
Nov 19 Gus Metzler New York, NY D 6
-Some sources report "D 8"
Nov 30 Billy Forsyth Bridgeport, Ct D 15
-Some sources report "D 10"
Dec 12 Gus Metzler Brooklyn, NY W 6
Dec 15 Jack Lynch Philadelphia, Pa SCH
-This bout was scheduled but cancelled; Hornbacher had an injured eye
Dec 21 Danny Russell Bridgeport, Ct LK 2
Johnny Breslin Boston, Ma D 8
1893
Feb 28 Owen Farley Newark, NJ L 10
1894
Mar 24 John Grant Stamford, Ct LT 5
-Some sources report "LF 5" on 03/25/1894
Oct 1 -Hornbacher was challenged by Johnny Breslin to a bout
Johnny Murphy West Orange, NJ EX
1895
Feb 9 Mike Mulroy Brooklyn, NY SCH
-This bout was scheduled; The outcome is not known
Feb 18 Tom Reynolds Jersey City, NJ SCH
-This bout was scheduled; The outcome is not known
Feb 25 Billy O'Conner Brooklyn, NY EX 3
Mar 16 Billy O'Conner Brooklyn, NY EX 3
May 11 Kid McPartland Brooklyn, NY SCH
-This bout was scheduled but Hornbacker refused to fight
since McPartland weighed over the limit
Jun 1 Eugene Garcia Brooklyn, NY W 8
Nov 5 Eddie Connolly SCH
-This bout was scheduled as a "private" fight but was cancelled
Nov 11 Charlie Matthews Hartford, Ct SCH
-This bout was scheduled; The outcome is not known
Nov 20 Billy O'Conner Brooklyn, NY EX
1896
Mar 7 Terry Lee Brooklyn, NY D 6
1897
Sep 20 Johnny "Midget" Glynn Brooklyn, NY L 10
Nov 23 Billy Forsyth Bridgeport, Ct D 8
-Some sources report "L 8"
Dec 31 Mike Lyons Brooklyn, NY LT 2
1898
May 28 Billy Gardner L 4
Oct 15 Jack Reynolds Brooklyn, NY D 10
1900
Jul 21 Eugene Garcia Brooklyn, NY LT 8
*** The Following Bouts Are Reported But Not Confirmed ***
Undated
Jimmy Dwyer L
Jack Boylan W
-Perhaps, this is a reference to the 06/01/1888 bout
Jack Shannon W 3
Jim Collins W 10
-Perhaps, this is a reference to the 04/15/1889 bout
Elwood McCloskey Philadelphia, Pa ND 4
1887
Feb Jim Stuart New York, NY W 4
Feb Walter Donahue New York, NY W 3
1888
Jan Tommy "Spider" Kelly New York, NY L 15
-Some sources report Jan 1889
1889
Jan Charles "Cal" McCarthy SCH
-This bout was scheduled; The outcome is not known
Jan 28 Tommy "Spider" Kelly Brooklyn, NY SCH
-This bout was scheduled; The outcome is not known
1895
Mar 24 Jack Grant New York, NY LF 5
-This appears to be a reference to the 03/24/1894 bout
*** Most Data Was Provided By William Schutte ***
Review courtesy of
Tracy Callis,
Historian, International Boxing Research Organization
|