1873
Bill Hayley
Leed Gate, England
KO 16
1873-1881
Jack Caradis
in England
KO
Jack Caradis
in England
KO
Jack Wepwell
in England
(30:00) KO
Sam Griffiths
in England
D 60
1881
Oct 15
-Fell arrived in America
1882
Bill Brady
KO 5
Jul 5 Jack McLaughlin
KO 5
Aug 22 Tommy McManus
Rich Hill, Ks
(20:00) TK 14
-London Prize Ring rules were used
Some sources report "W
14"
1883
Jul 13 Hugh McManus
near Kansas City, Mo
LF 92
1884
Feb 14
"Nonpareil" Jack Dempsey New York, NY
LT 2
-Some sources report "L 2"
Apr 5 O.H. Smith
Omaha, Ne
W 3
-Soft gloves were used
May 13 Jack Hanley
Clear Creek, Ne
(30:00) WF 22
-Some sources report "L"; This bout was held near
Denver, Co; Hanley was
arrested after the fight
and sentenced on May 24
1884 to three years
imprisonment at Nebraska
State Penitentiary; He
was released on Oct 25
1886; Fell escaped after
the fight and avoided
punishment; London Prize Ring
rules and bare knuckles
were used
Dec 12 Joe Popp
Toronto, Ont, Canada
KO 2
-Some sources report 12/13/84
1884-1885
Jack Cooper
New York, NY
W
-This bout was held during the fall of 1884 or early 1885;
Perhaps, this is the same
as the 2/09/85 or 3/06/85 bout
1885
Jan 22
"Nonpareil" Jack Dempsey New York, NY
L 4
Jan 26 Jim Fay
New York, NY
TK 3
-Some sources report "John Fay";
Some sources report "W
4";
Gloves were used for this
bout;
Jan 30 Jim Burns
New York, NY
SCH
-This bout was scheduled but not held; Burns did not show
Jan 30 John
Banks
New York, NY
LK 2
-Banks knocked Fell out; When Fell came
to, another round
was fought; Fell quit
after the third round
Feb 9 James Robertson Couper
New York, NY
KO 7
Mar 6 Jim McDevitt
New York, NY
KO 1
Mar 6 James Robertson Couper
New York, NY
TK 1
-The previous 2 bouts were held the same date
Mar 11 Harry Umlah
Hartford, Ct
KO 2
-Some sources report 3/12/85
Mar 20 John Hughes
in New Jersey
KO 5
Mar 30 John Banks
New York, NY
D 3
Apr 16 Denny Butler
Harlem, NY
KO 21
Jack Smith
W
"New York" Tom Allen
New York, NY
W
George Rooke
Cincinnati, Oh
ND
-Police intervened
Jul 10 Dan Collins
Hamilton, Ont, Canada
L 2
-Gloves were used
Aug 22 George Peters
Detroit, Mi
D 4
-Gloves were used; Some sources report "J. Peters"
Aug 27 Buck Fogle
Troy, NY
(6:00) W 2
-Some sources report "Buck Foyle"; Hard gloves were used
Sep 1 Buck Fogle
Dayton, Oh
KO 2
-Some sources report "Buck Foyle"
Sep 8 Alf Cliff
Port Huron, Mi
(7:00) W 2
-Hard gloves were used
Sep 17 Tom Robinson
Troy, NY
(23:00) D 6
-Hard gloves were used
Oct 2 Sam Grof
Dayton, Oh
(2:00) W 1
-Gloves were used
Oct 26 Gus Lambert
Montreal, Que, Canada
LK 2
-Championship of Canada
Nov 5 Billy Peters
Detroit, Mi
L 4
-Perhaps, this man was "George Peters";
Fell failed to knock out
Peters;
Peters knocked Fell down
in the 4th round
Nov 13 George Rooke
Cincinnati, Oh
ND 1
-Gloves were used; Police intervened
Nov 21 Dusty Gibbons
Detroit, Mi
(1:40) W 1
-Gloves were used
Dec 2 Tom O'Donnell
Howard City, Mi
KO 2
-Some sources report "W 2";
Hard gloves were used
1886
Jan 6 Tom Kinnard
Elmore, Mi
KO 5
Feb 9 Tom O'Donnell
Kalamazoo, Mi
D 4
-Police intervened; Some sources report "NC 4"
Feb 14 Jim McCormick
Kansas City, Mo
SCH
-This bout was scheduled but not held;
Police intervened and
prevented the fight;
This bout was possibly
held during 1883-1884
Apr 13 Jack Wyman
Alpena, Mi
KO 2
Apr 29 Harry Grebel
Detroit, Mi
KO 1
Jun 23 John Clow
Muskegon, Mi
D 12
-Police intervened: Clow was better and
should have won;
Some sources report "D
13" in "Denver, Co"
Jul 10 John
Clow
Cincinnati, Oh
SCH
-This bout was scheduled; The outcome is not known;
Gloves were to be used
for this bout
Oct 30 Jack Brady
McAllister Terrotory, SD ? SCH
-Brady was the "Champion of the Southwest";
This was a finish fight;
Gloves were to be used;
This bout was possibly
held during 1883-1884
1887
Dec 15 Peter J. Nolan
Grand Rapids, Mi
LF 3
-Perhaps, this bout was held at "Detroit, Mi"
1886-1888
Mike Conley
L
1888
Jan
-Fell challenged Jack Fallon
Feb 16 Harry Langdon
New York, NY
TK 1
-Some sources report "W 1"
Feb 17 Bob Ferguson
Long Island City, NY
WF 3
-Ferguson knocked down Fell and then kicked him;
Referee Jere Dunn
declared Fell winner by foul
Mar 19 Joe
Lannon
Brooklyn, NY
LT 2
-Police intervened; Lannon was about to
knock out Fell;
Some sources report "L
2"; Some sources report "ND 2"
Apr 18 Bob Ferguson
Hoboken, NJ
D 9
-Police intervened
May 15
George LaBlanche
SCH
-This bout was scheduled; The outcome is not known
May 23 James "Sparrow" Golden
Providence, RI
KO 5
-Some sources report 3/23/88
Jul 14 Jack Wannop
Grand Rapids, Mi
D 8
-Fox Rules were used for this bout;
Some sources report "W 8"
on 7/19/88;
Some sources report
7/12/88;
Some sources report
Wannop was better
Sep 30 Jim McCormick
Rhinelander, Wi
KO 2
Oct 2 John P. Donner
Duluth, Mn
L 6
-Fell failed to knock out Donner;
Some sources report 10/03/88
Oct 5 John W. Curtis
Duluth, Mn
WF 5
Oct 18 John P. Donner
Ashland, Wi
D 10
Oct 25 Jack Ashton
Providence, RI
L 12
-Gloves were used for this bout;
Some sources report "LF
12"
Dec 17 John W. Curtis
Eau Claire, Wi
D 7
-Perhaps, this bout was held 12/18/88
Police intervened
Dec 30 Mart Fahey
near Minneapolis, Mn
D 10
-Fahey threw Fell to the floor twice; In round nine, he
knocked Fell around the
ring and finally down; Fell was
very weak at the end;
Fell landed some hard blows during
the fight; Queensberry
Rules and two ounce gloves were used
1889
Jan 21
Patsy Cardiff
Minneapolis, Mn
L 15
-Gloves were used for this bout;
Some sources report "LF 15" on 1/22/89
May 11 Martin Flemming
Milwaukee, Wi
D 3
-Police intervened
Jul 3 Jim McCormick
Grand Rapids, Mi
ND 10
-This bout was scheduled and held; The outcome is not known
Sep 4 Black Diamond
Rhinelander, Wi
WF 5
-Perhaps, this man was "Harry Woodson"
Sep Frank Keller
Ashland, Wi
EX
Sep Frank Keller
Ashland, Wi
EX
Sep -Fell boxed
several exhibitions with Keller at Ashland, Wi
1890
Feb 12 Frank Keller
San Francisco, Ca
D 4
Mar 9 Jack McAuley
Salinas, Ca
KO 2
May 3 Billy Keough
Virginia City, Nv
LK 27
-Reports vary - "Billy Keogh" - "Billy Kehoe"
*** The Following Bouts Are Reported But Not Confirmed ***
Undated
"Denver" Ed Smith
SCH
C.A.C. Smith
SCH
-The previous 2 bouts were scheduled; The outcomes are not known